The Secret’s out – if you want to lower your ediscovery and litigation costs – seek F.R.E. 502 non-waiver orders
March 30th, 2009 | By Steve PuiszisHeriot v. Byrne, 2009 WL 742769 (N.D. Ill. March 20, 2009)
Heriot addresses the inadvertent production of privileged materials by an ediscovery vendor. Because the law firm that retained the vendor had taken reasonable steps to review the documents prior to their production, and took prompt steps to rectify the inadvertant disclosure once they learned of it, the court ruled the disclosure was inadvertent and did not result in a waiver attorney-client privilege under Fed. R. Evid. 502(b). The decision also serves as a stark reminder of the care which must be taken in selecting an ediscovery vendor, and the American Bar Association Ethics Opinion addressing a lawyer’s obligations when outsourcing legal and nonlegal services.
However, after reading the court’s analysis of the parties’ Rule 502(b) arguments, I was struck by how unnecessary it all was. I tried to imagine the number of hours the district court spent reviewing the documents which had been submitted for an in camera inspection, reviewing the parties’ briefs, and then drafting its opinion resolving the Rule 502(b) issues that were presented. I thought of the hours, and literally the thousands of dollars that were wasted litigating the inadvertent waiver issue. Much of that time, money and effort could have been avoided had the parties simply entered into a non-waiver order under Fed. R. Evid. 502(d).
So, before stepping off the soap box and getting back to Heriot, let us provide a practical suggestion to lower your ediscovery and litigation costs – enter into non-waiver orders under Fed. R. Evid. 502(d). The Note to Rule 502(d) explains that once a non-waiver order is entered in a federal proceeding, “its terms are enforceable against non-parties in any federal or state proceeding.” That Note further explains the agreement of the parties is not a condition to the entry of, or the enforceability of a non-waiver order. As indicated in one of our prior posts, Rule 502 non-waiver orders are the gold standard to follow when seeking protection against the inadvertent waiver of privilege.
Leave a Comment »